Published on

Using TensorFlow in MES Systems

Authors
  • avatar
    Name
    Martin Szerment

What is TensorFlow?

TensorFlow is an open-source library developed by Google for building deep learning models as well as traditional machine learning algorithms.

Application in MES Systems

TensorFlow enables the development of advanced models based on neural networks for analyzing large and complex industrial datasets.

Implementation Process:

  1. Data Preparation:

    • MES data is organized in time-series streams (e.g., temperature, vibrations, pressure).
    • Data is normalized and missing values are filled in.

  2. Model Architecture:

    • TensorFlow allows building RNN (Recurrent Neural Networks) or LSTM (Long Short-Term Memory) networks for analyzing time series.
    • For state classification, a simple MLP (Multilayer Perceptron) can be applied.

  3. Model Training:

    • The model learns from historical machine state data.
    • TensorFlow's neural networks can automatically detect complex relationships in data.

  4. Detection and Prediction:

    • The model analyzes input data in real time and classifies the current machine state.
    • Based on trend analysis, it can also predict potential failures.

Comparison of TensorFlow with XGBoost, LightGBM, and CatBoost

1. Execution Speed

  • XGBoost, LightGBM, CatBoost:
    Gradient boosting algorithms are significantly faster in training and prediction compared to TensorFlow. They perform efficiently even on machines with limited computational power.
    • Training Time: Shorter (minutes or hours for medium datasets).
    • Prediction Time: Extremely fast (milliseconds).
  • TensorFlow:
    TensorFlow requires more computational power, especially for deep learning networks like LSTM.
    • Training Time: Dependent on resources – on GPU or TPU, it may take hours or days.
    • Prediction Time: Slower than boosting algorithms, especially for large models.

2. Resource Usage

  • XGBoost, LightGBM, CatBoost:

    • Require less memory and computational power.
    • Perform well on CPUs, making them efficient on standard servers.

  • TensorFlow:

    • Requires more computational power (GPU or TPU) and higher RAM usage.
    • More resource-intensive, especially for applications involving large neural networks.

3. Accuracy

  • XGBoost, LightGBM, CatBoost:

    • Very accurate in classifying states in tabular data.
    • Slightly less effective in analyzing time-series data.

  • TensorFlow:

    • Superior for analyzing complex data, such as time-series or multidimensional data.
    • High accuracy in detecting nonlinear relationships but requires careful optimization.

4. Flexibility

  • XGBoost, LightGBM, CatBoost:

    • Easier to implement.
    • Ideal for tabular data.

  • TensorFlow:

    • Greater flexibility and the ability to build advanced models.
    • Perfect for analyzing time-series, images, and multidimensional data.

When to Choose TensorFlow?

  • Time-Series Analysis: For time-series streams like temperature, pressure, or vibrations, TensorFlow (e.g., LSTM models) outperforms gradient boosting algorithms.
  • Complex Dependencies: If the data has a complex structure, TensorFlow handles modeling it better.

When to Choose XGBoost, LightGBM, or CatBoost?

  • Tabular Data: Gradient boosting algorithms are more efficient and easier to implement for tabular data, such as machine failure history.
  • Limited Computational Resources: If you lack GPU resources or need quick results, boosting algorithms are a better choice.

Summary

Performance and Resources:

  • If speed and low resource usage are priorities, gradient boosting algorithms (XGBoost, LightGBM, CatBoost) are better.
  • For analyzing complex dependencies, especially in time-series data, TensorFlow can be more effective.

Recommendations:

  • Choose XGBoost, LightGBM, or CatBoost if:

    • Your data is tabular.
    • You need quick predictions and straightforward deployment.

  • Choose TensorFlow if:

    • You are analyzing time-series or multidimensional data.
    • You have access to GPU/TPU resources and prioritize accuracy.

Both approaches have their use cases and can also be applied hybridly, where TensorFlow analyzes time-series data, and boosting algorithms handle classification in tabular data.

← Back to the blog